Originally Posted by
jimbob
I have always questioned catch and release mortality rates. I don't believe that they are as high as they say, A fish is definitly stressed after having been caught but I think that they will be fine if released in thier natural water. During the studies on fishing mortality, the fish are caught by rod and reel then placed in tanks and transported to a place where they are observed over time. I think that many of those fish die of added stress of captivity.
As far as just letting the fish lay there until they recover on thier own. I think it is a bad idea, if the fish just lays there for a few minutes It could wind up as prey for seals or sharks or bluefish or ospreys. I have had sharks and seals chase Bass I have hooked, and I have seen ospreys take Stripers from the surf.
I would think that we should give the fish the best chance we can, we owe it to them for the recreation they provide us.