Action alert: Old Bridge shore access and EPA meeting update thread
Hey guys there is a meeting on Wednesday April 1, 7pm at the Old Bridge Police HQ/Town hall at Cottrell ave and Rt 516, Old Bridge.
At this meeting, EPA representatives will be there to discuss and take questions from the general public on any comments or concerns about the proposed fencing of the beach taking place in less than 2 weeks.
Some fishermen fish that area in the early spring and then move on, so it might not get as much focus as Brookhaven, Long Branch, or someplace else.
Fencing in the proposed area:
1. Will push fishermen into other areas, resulting in overcrowding.
2. Will not prevent fishing access by kayakers, boaters, only fishermen on foot.
3. Seems discriminatory against the shore bound fisherman.
Details of contamination:
I talked to quite a few people about this, and each time got different stories. Anyone who has any specific details please put them in the thread.
Action Plan/Remediation:
If anyone of you guys out there know any groups who fish that area and might get involved, Wednesday might be the last chance we get to speak out for fishermen. Please try to go to the meeitng if you live nearby, or ever fish there. Please relay this info to any site or fishermen you think people might be able to help.
Details and News articles
http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/200...tan_bay_s.html
http://stripersandanglers.com/Forum/...ead.php?t=3382
Feds seek closure of three Raritan Bay sites due to lead levels
by Aliyah Shahid/ For The Star-Ledger Thursday March 19, 2009, 8:46 AM
The Environmental Protection Agency has called for the immediate closing of three waterfront sites along the Raritan Bay in Old Bridge and Sayreville due to health concerns after finding high levels of lead in the area.
"We found very, very high levels of lead," Walter Mugdan, the EPA's director of the Emergency and Remedial Response Division for the region, said earlier this week. "It's way above what anybody would think would be appropriate. ... It's a matter of concern."
http://blog.nj.com/ledgerupdates_imp...arge_olrar.JPGPatti Sapone/The Star-LedgerOld Bridge Waterfront Park in Old Bridge.
Mugdan said the contaminated soil was found around the western jetty near Cheesequake Creek in Old Bridge, at a small beach north of the jetty in Sayreville, and at the Laurence Harbor sea wall in Old Bridge. The EPA has recommended those areas be closed immediately.
According to the EPA's website, lead is considered a hazard when it is equal to or exceeds 1,200 parts per million in children's play areas.
At the Laurence Harbor sea wall area, the range of lead sampled was as high as 142,000 parts per million. The sea wall is about 2,345 feet long.
At the western jetty near Cheesequake Creek, the highest levels found were 198,000 parts per million. The average in the area was 52,399 parts per million. The jetty's size depends on the tide, but is about 755 feet long and 20 to 30 feet wide.
At a half-acre beach area in Sayreville, just north of the Cheesequake Creek jetty, the range of lead sampled was the same as at the jetty -- as high as 142,000 parts per million.
The EPA conducted the tests last September and released the results last week.
Mugdan said he was particularly concerned about children playing on the beach, as they might accidentally ingest sand or track sand from their shoes inside their homes. He also said fishermen who stand on nearby jetties could also be exposed.
Extreme exposure to lead can cause neurological damage, kidney disease, cardiovascular problems and reproductive toxicity, according to the EPA website.
Mugdan said the EPA is awaiting test results that will determine if fish and other marine creatures have been affected.
Wednesday morning, Jerry Bonnett, 69, of Westfield, was one of about 10 fishermen casting their lines into the waters near Cheesequake Creek. Bonnett was hoping to catch dinner for his family. Dressed in waist-high, khaki waders and black rubber boots, Bonnett said he has been fishing in the area for 40 years.
The area is popular with fishermen and while swimming is prohibited, bathers are sometimes seen in the water.
Old Bridge Business Administrator Michael Jacobs said the township is cooperating with the EPA and hopes to have signs and split-rail fences up in the next few weeks. Jacobs said previous tests conducted by the state Department of Environmental Protection did not reveal how widespread the problem was. "The EPA found lead outside of that scope, in areas we didn't know about. We were surprised, but are going to do whatever the EPA tells us," he said.
While the EPA isn't ready to point fingers, the mayors of Sayreville and Old Bridge, in a statement last week, blamed former paint manufacturer National Lead Industries for the contamination. National Lead owned a 400-acre paint pigment manufacturing plant in Sayreville and a refining operation in Perth Amboy until the 1980s.
Several calls this week to National Lead Industries, whose headquarters are in Dallas, were not returned.
Beth Totman, an EPA spokeswoman said it's too early to address blame and the goal now is to begin cleanup. She said there are cases where the EPA funds projects and then retroactively enforces payment from a party it later deems responsible for the contamination.
Lead slag was used to create a sea wall in Laurence Harbor in the late 1960s and early 1970s. Over the years, lead chipped off the sea wall and has been found on nearby beaches, Old Bridge Mayor James Phillips said.
Sayreville Mayor Kennedy O'Brien said his borough has been aggressively seeking proposals to redevelop the beachfront.
"We have the opportunity to create a great waterfront amenity for the people of Sayreville," he said. "National Lead needs to work with the EPA to conduct an immediate and comprehensive remediation program. Because we know the responsible party, there is no reason for this project to languish."
Mugdan said the boroughs asked that the EPA to place the sites on a Superfund list so federal money would be available for the cleanup. But that would mean more tests. "It's not going to happen in a month or even a year," he said. "My guess is on a site like this, a longer-term remedy will be needed."
In the meantime, some fisherman, like Bonnett, will continue to fish. "I've been fishing here forever," he said, adding after a moment of reflection, "But I might advise my grandchildren not to."
Old Bridge Public meeting with EPA and concerned citizens 4-1-09
The meeting was pretty well attended by town residents. Honestly, I thought a few more fishermen might have decided to come down, but the ones that came made some good points and raised some important questions.
Blanche from town hall coordinated all the questions and answers, she did a great job. :clapping:
Overview:
The EPA officials presented the findings, showed us some maps of where the contamination was found, and talked about the areas that would be closed. They were helpful in answering almost everyone's questions, and offered to come back, sit in on meetings in the future, and keep a dialogue going. There were websites and hotlines posted so people could get the latest info and findings. When that stuff becomes available, I'll post it here. I'll also post the links.
I'm trying to do this by being fair and balanced, and present the good with the bad. I don't think it's smart for anyone who writes about this, whether in the newspapers, magazines, or internet forums, to talk about how the sky is falling. Yeah, the contamination there is serious. If a diligent effort was made to dig soil samples, I would guess there might be some levels of chemical contamination at many points of the Raritan Bay. You could also probably go to any bay near a major metropolitan area along the East Coast and find some level of chemical contamination, somewhere. Chemicals have been dumped down storm sewers and in rivers for years without thought of the consequences. Unfortunately, they wind up in the bays and estuaries.
Realistically, the levels of lead contamination from Sayreville to Cliffwood are horrendously above the recommended maximums. This closure could very well be one of the largest Superfund sites in recent years. There's no way to sugercoat this. From the charts they presented to us, IMO this thing will get a lot bigger than reported by the time they're done with all the testing. I feel this is just the tip of the iceberg.
However, since I started reporting on stuff like this, I realized we who report have an ethical responsibility.
Reporting the truth is admirable. Reporting the truth so it panics people is not being fair and balanced, in my opinion. So I hope this story I'm laying down here will come out as fair and balanced.
I try my best, but anyone who has any factual corrections to what I report here, please let me know and I will edit. I don't want to scare people here. If some of my words mobilize people to take action to get this place cleaned up sooner rather than later, I will feel I've made a contribution. Thanks for reading, people. :D
Raritan bay superfund site links for info
I'm putting up a few links here, anyone else who wants feel free to put links or contacts up.
Old Bridge Township website:
http://www.oldbridge.com/
Re: Action alert: Old Bridge shore access and EPA meeting update thread
Here is the latest. I think it will take more than 10 years. 2 years and they still have done nothing. dark thanks for all the work you put in on this.
http://blog.nj.com/njv_mark_diionno/...ndustrial.html
Di Ionno: Ghosts of industrial past keep Laurence Harbor from its beach
Published: Sunday, June 24, 2012, 8:20 AM
OLD BRIDGE TWP. — The Jersey Shore starts at Laurence Harbor, a section of Old Bridge Township. The Middlesex County hamlet is unmistakably a beach town; it sits on a bluff overlooking the Raritan Bay, with clear-day views of Sandy Hook, Long Island, and the expanse of ocean beyond.
In the center is a large parking lot with a bathhouse pavilion to accommodate beachgoers. There’s a bait shop right there, pizza and ice cream a few steps away.
Shoreland Circle, the residential street that overlooks the boardwalk and dunes, is a mixed collection of old narrow bungalows, and those recently expanded and modernized. Except for the hill, it looks like a neighborhood in any beachfront town, from Manasquan to Long Beach Island.
But the parking lot is empty these days, and the bathhouse is closed. A lone port-a-potty is all that’s needed.
There is no endless summer in Laurence Harbor these days. Just endless frustration. And unanswered questions. And a long, high, black chain-link fence that keeps most of the beach closed.
In the spring of 2009, the federal Environmental Protection Agency closed most of Laurence Harbor’s beaches and put 1.3 miles of Middlesex County waterfront on its list of Superfund sites. Now another summer is here, and will go, before the beach reopens. And maybe another. And maybe another.
The problem is lead-laden slag, which was taken from the old National Lead industrial site in Sayreville, where Dutch Boy paint was made, and used to anchor jetties and bolster the seawall in the area.
The EPA has a "preferred remedy" for the site, but will not make it public until next month. After that, there will be a 30- to 45-day public hearing period, ending either around or after Labor Day. And after that, well, who knows?
"We can’t discuss the proposal until it is made public," said Elias Rodriguez, a spokesman for the EPA, who added no exact date in July has been decided. "At that point, we’ll put forth several proposals, including our preferred remedy. Any cleanup schedule is contingent on the remediation plan that is decided."
Most people in Laurence Harbor take it in stride. What else can they do?
"I got over being angry two years ago," said Donna Wilson, who was working on her elaborate garden on her property, which overlooks the shoreline.
She bought one of the shotgun shacks for $395,000 a few years back — "I didn’t buy the bungalow, I bought the beautiful corner lot, and the view," she said — and began renovating right away. But within a year, the fences and warning signs went up.
A bungalow two doors down is now on the market for $260,000.
"I don’t worry too much about that," she said. "Because I’m staying for good, and I know that someday, I hope anyway, the beaches will reopen."
http://brightcove01.brightcove.com/2...d=260701700001
Residents of the Laurence Harbor section of Old Bridge are hoping for an end to the Raritan Bay superfund siteIt was during the 1960s and 1970s that a company called National Lead deposited slag throughout the seawall in Raritan Bay to help prevent erosion along the shoreline. Slag, is a byproduct from the lead refining process that contains toxic heavy metals. The lead stayed there for decades. It was in 2009, when the Environmental Protection Agency determined the water was unsafe for people. The beach has been fenced in and off limits ever since. (Video by Andre Malok / The Star-Ledger)
Watch video
In the three years since the beach was cordoned off, the word "slag" became part of the vernacular of the Middlesex County waterfront.
By definition, slag is "the vitreous mass left as a residue by the smelting of metallic ore."
In Middlesex, it is a vitreous mess left as the residue of heavy industry that once dominated the bayshore, then made worse by the decision 50 years ago to use the slag on the seawalls and jetties. The 2,500 feet of seawall in Laurence Harbor have shown elevated levels of lead, antimony, arsenic and copper.
The word "slag" is now synonymous with frustration.
"You wonder what the holdup is," said Dana Stovall, who watched as her son Jaydon Tortorello, 8, ran around the playground just a few yards from the fenced-off slag. "They put up the fence and that was that. Nobody’s cleaning it up."
Most of the slag on the Middlesex waterfront is in an industrial waste-product called kettle bottoms; the hardened gunk left over in the smelting process. The kettle bottoms are easy to spot. They anchor the jetty at Cheesequake Creek in the Morgan section of Sayreville, and were dumped among the granite boulders along the seawall. Unlike the natural rocks, the kettle bottoms are burnt-orange in color, and rusted or pockmarked with corrosion. They are dense and impossibly heavy.
The slag contamination stretches from the creek jetty to Cliffwood Beach, which, like Laurence Harbor, is a part of Old Bridge Township.
But there are places along the way where beaches are open, side by side with those closed. Part of the community frustration with the beach closing lies in what is still open. The fishing jetty at Cheesequake Creek is closed, but the adjacent beach, just yards away, is open.
"I’m trying to understand this contamination," said Peter Insalaco, who owns the bait shop and tackle shop at Laurence Harbor. "If there’s so much lead, why is the water safe here (the open beach) and not there (the closed)."
While most of the Laurence Harbor Beach is closed, the boardwalk, jetty, playground and walking path are open. So is the beach just a few feet from the closed section, where Nicole Oropallo waded in to put her kayak in the water.
"It would be nice if they got it cleaned up," she said. "But on the other hand, it’s nice that it is so quiet. When nobody’s here, I can let my dogs run."
Insalaco said the presence of the fence is "killing business in the area."
He opened his shop, Tackle U.S., last year, after the previous owner went out of business two years before.
"I opened hoping the beach would reopen soon," he said.
In fact, the area was reopened for fishing.
"That’s what doesn’t make sense," he said. "How bad can it be? That fence has got to go. It’s keeping the community down."
For Stovall, when the fences come down, life will return to normal. She once lived in a bungalow on Shoreline Drive, the house where Jaydon’s father grew up.
"He swam in this water since he was a kid," she said. "So did Jaydon. He keeps asking, ‘When will we be able to go back in the water?’"
Re: Action alert: Old Bridge shore access and EPA meeting update thread
Thanks for the kind words, Ledhead and others.
I spent a lot of time going to those initial meetings, was even quoted in the news when I stood up, made a few criticisms of the EPA and their history of foot-dragging, and the townspeople gave me a standing ovation.
That felt good, but in the long run I really wanted to raise awareness of folks who would be hurt by this issue, as well as fishermen access.
I have been fighting for fishermen access for a good number of years now, and it seems that each year there is more apathy, unless guys are directly affected......
I have news for you folks reading this,,..
Access, once lost, is very hard to get back....
We saw this at Brookhaven/Shoreham in LI.
We have seen it on the jetty that marks the beginning of Highlands Harbor in NJ.
We have seen it at St Alphonse's retreat in Long Branch (incidentally Pebbles and I walked that beach the other day, and it's a crying shame to me that fishermen ruined it for themselves with the fantastic and easy access we had there)......
So for you folks who think it can't happen to your area...think again....and please think of getting involved the next time you hear of an access issue.....
Thanks again for the kind words, they mean a lot....:thumbsup: :HappyWave:
Re: Action alert: Old Bridge shore access and EPA meeting update thread
Dark thank you for your activism but you are still a googan!
Go the see the post in the surfcasting forum, goog fisherman, and see what I came up with. Hope you like it, just kidding! :HappyWave:
Re: Action alert: Old Bridge shore access and EPA meeting update thread
Good job dark. I remember the work you put in at Shoreham. Thanks for all.
Re: Action alert: Old Bridge shore access and EPA meeting update thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
DarkSkies
We have seen it at St Alphonse's retreat in Long Branch (incidentally Pebbles and I walked that beach the other day, and it's a crying shame to me that fishermen ruined it for themselves with the fantastic and easy access we had there)......
So for you folks who think it can't happen to your area...think again....and please think of getting involved the next time you hear of an access issue.....
Thanks again for the kind words, they mean a lot....:thumbsup: :HappyWave:
Amen dude. I was there but did not see that argument. There were some mexicans that were cleaning fish with a hose that belonged to the retreat too. I would like to meet that guy that was giving the priest a hard time. Would like to lump him upside the head. Maybe twice for good measure. You can still fish there but back then it was so easy, park right there and walk 200' to the surf. It was like a whos who of nj surfmen. Man I miss those days.
Follow up on the original meeting.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hrpz3C1mOEo
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HhssvwIkX74