If you could only take 5 things to fish at Montauk

[albiealert]

what would they be? - thinking of going, bringing some big plugs, any other thoughts?

[SharkHart]

Pencils, shads, bucktails, maybe some metal if they are out far. Pencils dominate though, there is a lot of rooted grass in close and non topwater gets stuck on it often and it can be annoying.

[crosseyedbass]

Agreed love using pencils and bucktails up there. Maybe its time to make another trip.

[stripercrazy]

Pencils or bottle plugs
Bucktails
Big swimmers for the south side
Rubber shads, depends on the bait around
Water, water and more water

[voyager35]

I'd bring some bucktails, poppers, and bombers and two poles.

[surfstix1963]

Darters,bottle darters,bucktails,pencils and floating poppers.

[Doublerunner]

1. My friends
2. Bucktails with pork rind
3. Pencil poppers
4. Eels
5. Darters

[Jackbass]

Bucktails WHite
Darters Yellow
Pencils White /red head
Surface Swimmer Olive over white
Yellow Needle slow sinking

[dogfish]

Eels, eels, eels,eels, live eels, dead eels rigged, eels on ice, a few dozen. If not that the list below covers it well.

Darters,bottle darters,bucktails,pencils and floating poppers.

[jimmy z]

Three darters and two pencils or two darters and three pencils.

[SurfPlug]

Bucktails along with rind is a must along with darters, needles, metal lip swimmers, and pencil poppers.