Some more thoughts, thanks to the OGB, as always, for the wealth of experience he helps add to some of my thoughts....(for I am just an ornery Googan....)
CATCHING Albies When they're Picky....or feeding on Small Bait.....2012....
Unless you're willing to run to the bluefish grounds, albies have been feeding closer, in tight. They are in and out. A great time to target them has been sunrise and an hour after. In some places this also depends on the amount of forage and tide stage.
Also try to stay out till end of day. There has been some consistent small bluefish and albie action where the bay meets the ocean. Small metals, as mentioned.
There is a difference in albie behavior when they are out in the chum slicks, where they and sometimes tuna will hit bunker, and not be spooked by a wire leader.
When they are further inshore chasing very small bait, IMO they're much more challenging to catch. Lately, some guys have been hit and miss with them. The feedback I'm getting is that depending on when and where, sometimes even the length of the metal is an issue.
So if they're crashing schools of rainfish, for example, the behavior is different than when they are cruising around a chum slick seeing chunks of meat. They become much more selective.
Again, only my experience, but when that happens, smaller is better, as some have mentioned.
Even a feather might be too big. An
old school way is to set up a short soda straw with a sturdy gold hook at the end and troll it. I don't know if you want to go to that much trouble. However it does work and will increase your catch ratio when they are picky.
Or you could try feathers.